Humanistic Approaches to Positive Growth and Self-Acceptance
Home » What Would You Do?
THE BYSTANDER EFFECT:
The thought of people witnessing a potential child abduction and not intervening is very scary. I do not have children of my own but I have nieces, a nephew and many cousins that would be unable to defend themselves against an abductor. If I were to witness anything similar to this video I would first observe from a short distance to rule out if the child was being disobedient to their parent. I would then call 911 and intervene. I would much rather falsely accuse a parent of being a child abductor then to let an actual child abductor free.
I agree that people are afraid to get involved when they see things like this going on. I would like o believe that i would react. True some people could think this is just another disobedient kid who doesn’t want to listen to their parents. I feel that i would have some ‘sixth sense’ telling me something wasn’t right. I probably would call 911 and explain the situation to them and keep and eye out to see where they go and report it to the dispatcher. This is the reason why when i am out with kids in my family, I do not allow them to be too far from me. I watch the show criminal mind and I really believe there are people out in the world that just want to cause harm. I’d like to believe I am cautious of my surroundings
After watching this video, I can say that it’s very disheartening to see that people can witness a child abduction and convince themselves that what it’s happening in front of them is not real. Maybe they thought the child was being a “brat” and misbehaving to her father. However, if I heard the words “let me go, you’re not my father” followed by “somebody please help me” repeatedly, my gut would tell me to confront the child/man and ask what’s going on. It is hard to say exactly what I’d do if in a situation like this until it actually happens. I want to give huge kudos to the 2 men who not only recognized something was really off about the whole scene but also taking what I believe was the appropriate action for something like the video displayed. Child Abduction is a very real and serious matter. Even if you don’t have kids, it should be obvious as to why being reactive during one is necessary.
When I saw some white people pass by the girl without any action, I’m so disappointed. But when those two black men run to the girl to help her, I’m proud of them. I once think white people are helpful and enthusiastic. But from this video, I changed my mind. Most of the time they just pretend to be very enthusiastic, but when it comes to the crunch, they always fall back. I acknowledge most of the people will afraid of this situation, and they don’t wanna take the risk. But at least they need to call the 911. It is a so cold-blooded behavior that people just look back to the little girl and left.
When I saw this video I was totally disappointed by looking the reaction of people.Firstly I feel there was no mercy and humanity among the people but secondly, when I saw two guys run toward the girl to help her I feel so happy and it’s make water in my eyes.Nowdays people are afraid to be in this kind of situation some how it’s good to be safe but there is so many way to help, e.g.:people can take help by call to 911.
A few things that I really liked from this video is the emphasis of different actions for different people, everyone has a role to play. Even if you can’t be the one who tackles the suspect or chase him or her, you can be the one to call the police. The important thing is to do something, to TAKE ACTION. When you choose to do nothing that is still a decision you are making.
It is honestly disheartening that in spite of the little girl’s screams no one wanted to check if the girl was okay. I understand how situation can be interpreted as disobedience, but you can never be too sure, you’re better safe then sorry.
I honestly don’t know what I would do in this situation, all I can say is that I hope to God that I would intervene in some way. We have to keep in mind that we won’t regret or get I trouble for ensuring the safety of someone. If presented with an issue if you don’t take action when you’re prompted to, who will?
It really doesn’t take a lot to help someone in need, especially a child. How do you live with yourself knowing you walked by a little girl screaming for help and you did nothing. The question is what if it was YOUR neighbor’s kid? would it make a difference? would you help because you knew her? Just imagine for a split second that it was Your kid. Wouldn’t you want someone to come to her rescue. Wouldn’t you want someone to speak up for her, r fight for her? It breaks my heart to see her scream her lungs out, and people just went on with their day. It’s sad, really. What a cruel world we live in…You don’t have to put yourself in harm’s say, just call 911, and stay there till the police arrive. It really doesn’t take much.
It really doesn’t take a lot to help someone in need especially a child. How do you live with yourself knowing you walked by a little girl asking for help and you did nothing. The real question is what if it was your neighbor’s kid? would it make a difference? would you act up then? Just imagine for a split second that it was Your child going through that… wouldn’t you want someone to come to her rescue? wouldn’t you want someone to stand up and fight for her. It breaks my heart to see that little girl screaming her lungs out and no one did nothing. They just went on about their day… It’s sad really. What a cruel world we live in. You don’t have to get yourself in harm’s way just call 911 and report what you see, tell them to send someone, or just stay and observe some more until the police arrive. IT really doesn’t take up much, you just have to be WILLING to do your part.
what would I do? to be honest, I would be scared too and won’t run to help her. At the same time, I will be disturbed if I just walk pass them..so I definitely would observe.. should the situation escalates.. its good idea to talk to the other bystanders and collect support.. individually you are weak but with help, the decisions become stronger and the action helpful and productive. its disappointing to see several bystanders turning blind and walking by. true they might have thought, its just a kid acting up with their family amongst other reason. in broad daylight if a child can be kidnapped like this, its terrifying..only when you are vulnerable then you think of our common weakness and behavior. its absolutely important to assess our own moral and integrity from time to time . apart from education and materialistic goal , every one should be encouraged to take social and moral responsibility so that we can count on each other at least. our humanity in us needs to be alive.
I hate to say it ,but realisticly I would not have been proactive because I would have thought maybe its a misbehaving child and her step father or something. It’s kind of scary to think that a child could be taken by a stranger yet bystander affect is strong. I’m glad those guys did something. I would at most have tried to say something to the police officer now. IAs for the new technology, it seems a bit off i think the pictures would work better.
I would like to I would do something but honestly not sure if I would have done anything at all. Maybe approach the person and ask if everything’s ok. But nowadays with both the law protecting parents and children I would think that if i were wrong and made a big deal about it then i’d probably be sued for defamation or whatnot. I would definitely at least say something though, apart from that I’m not sure.
To be honest, I don’t know what I would do. Because deep inside I definitely want to help, but would I be able to make my thought into action in the situation? I don’t know, but I pretty sure I might trying to help some ways, at least I won’t ignore it. I might ask people and gather people together to see what’s going on. And then looking for police if no one wanted to help. According to the video, it’s reasonable to evaluate the amount of danger I might put myself in if I get involve. But it’s really important that people acknowledge the problem and trying to help in some way, walking by and ignore it will not be the solution to end this problem. Because what if is one of their relative or daughter in danger, it will be tragedy when everyone step off and let it happen. So one way to overcome the bystander effect will be put yourself in their shoes, in order to understand there’s necessary action needed to be take, and every single one of us are carrying this duty. Pretend we are that girl, then we will understands how desperately we would wanted people to help instead walking away.
When something like this happens in public, everyone’s first reaction is to observe, and it’s not only restricted to these type of situations too. When it comes to arguments, physical fights, rowdy behavior, most people will do nothing, but observe. It’s tragic that’s this is how society’s mentally is set up. If I were to have witnessed this, I would have probably assumed this was just a child acting up, and just watch, maybe even comment to myself or whoever is with me on how some children are raised. I probably would’ve said something about the parent’s and their parenting. It’s the sad truth. It would’ve killed me to be watching the news later that day, and seeing the little girl’s face on the news knowing that I witnessed the abduction, and could’ve done something about it. Also, many thoughts would float in my mind about the circumstances, and if I should take action, for example, what if that really was a parent trying to control their misbehaving child, and I called the cops for no reason? What if this happened in a quiet area? No one would hear me scream if the person tried to take me too. What if the person was a person who is shameless, and tried to hurt me regardless if there was a crowd around? The feeling of wanting to protect your own self has consequences for others. This shows that humanity has to change together so we can learn how to protect one other.
Just as with the Genovese report, I wonder if an urban location attributes to a call to action versus onlookers falling prey to the “Bystander Effect.’ As was mentioned in the video by the interviewer, the child’s specific verbage likely played a key role in spurring onlooker’s call to action; the lines weren’t always the same for each test scenario. That said, in some cases the verbage was the same, i.e. “You’re not my dad.” In this particular scenario, were I the one walking by I would be drawn to the child’s screams, but then ultimately dismiss them as ‘kids being kids’ if I didn’t hear that key phrase “You’re not my dad.” As the tester marked, it is not always a similar action that people use to respond. Although off camera, he did mention there was a senior who had taken to calling police on her cell phone. It’s important in scenarios of potential danger or threat that we take the moments to fully assess the situation to determine if action is needed. I believe culture plays a big role in our willingness to help.
This test is about observed different actions from different age group or different gender. In this video, there were only two young people look back, and observed a while. They decided to chase the guy. Indeed, they were probably thinking should they do it or let others do it, but they finally decided to help the little girl. Moreover, there was a lady who was holding a phone and calling the police. Even the lady knows that she cannot help anything physically, but she has the ability to call the police. Different gender has their own different action to help. However, there was an adult and a kid just walking pass the girl. The adult obviously didn’t want to help no matter it is real or not. Only the kid looked back and watching the girl. The kid probably wanted to help, but because of his dad refused to help. He had to follow his father. Furthermore, the old couples watched the whole event, but they didn’t want to do anything. They probably thought it was a fake event. The girl was angry at her dad. So she acts like the guy is not her father. Old people think they have seen many events like this before. Many of them are fake. So they judge it immediately, and do not want to double check was it real or fake. Finally, the conclusion is young people have educated, they know how to determine different even. When someone needed their help, they can have the ability to do different actions to help. However, the old people stop learning from the society. They think their experience is unique, they thought they have the ability to see what is real or fake. They also think that they do not need to help anyone because they were growing in that specific environment which taught them do not help people with no benefits.
Well, I am not surprise that many people just walked by to scene not doing anything to figure out what was going on. That also happens with a lot of the bullying that we grow up seeying on the streets, and school… Most of the people dont do anything to try to help… I would stop and ask what was going on… But luckly, we still have some good people out there to show the world that the real superheroes are the ones that take the time to observe around, help, and make a difference in the world.
people have different views and interpretations of certain situations. I would not be involved physically, but I would definetly call 911.
This actually reminds me of the ABC show What Would You Do? It’s a hidden camera show where there are real life scenarios and real people are put to the test. In the video, many people just didn’t do anything to help the little girl and they didn’t want to get involved. I honestly would have expected a lot more people to react in a more proactive way, but I guess people were scared. However, they are different actions for different people and if someone isn’t able to physically step in them, they are able to call the police and help in that aspect.
On one hand I think people are very much afraid to get involve but on the other hand I bet some of these people just thought that this child was throwing a fit. Either way its wrong that almost no one stopped to see what was going on consider she was yelling out “you’re not my dad”. This is a little girl we’re talking about, how could someone question what was happening and not do anything about it?
I think it makes me wonder a bit that if this was not a skit, would this still happen. I was completely surprised to see people look back but not do anything knowing the child is yelling and confirming that she is basically being kidnapped. Although there were people that ended up helping but that means that there isn’t always that type of people around.
I think the problem (in my opinion) with this one was that this was acting, and it was at times a bit obvious, plus the way the guys was talking to her at the beginning (“don’t you ever run away like that” or something to that effect). I think all of this together, plus this happening in a daylight, in a public crowded place, created just enough doubt in people’s mind that they could not believe that they are actually witnessing a kidnapping, this is why it took so long for someone to react. But at the end several people reacted and not only the three guys trying to chase him, but an elderly lady started to dialing 911. So, when no one was reacting, it was easier for people to dismiss the situation, but as soon as there was a FIRST reaction from someone (was it the guy in the car or the two guys walking?) – more people joined in on the action.
Why is it that in a crowd people are more reluctant to jump in and help someone? Why would someone be less inclined to call the police if there was a crime? It comes from the idea that someone else is bound to help, and that brings the issue up that if everyone is thinking that way then no help will come. I have been placed in a situation like that where someone is on the ground not moving around a crowd first thing I did was call 9-1-1. I just really cant believe if you here someone screaming for help you just ignore them.
I have to agree with one of the comments above regarding the skit seeming obvious. I think some of the bystanders could pick up on the fact that it was not a real life situation and these people were acting. It also does make you think for the people who didn’t know it was fake, what would it take for someone to help or call 911. I think the two guys are courageous for acting so quickly and trying to come to her rescue no matter the consequences. A lot of people in this world are in too much of a rush or stuck in their own world that they don’t notice their surroundings or the things happening around them. If this were me in the situation, I would rather be safe than sorry.
Watching the video, as I watched the bystanders were around and they witnessed the kidnapping in daylight, the first thing i saw was not many people were reacting that surprised. Though the acting of the kidnapping wasn’t exactly a Hollywood production and acting, I saw some of the people actually walking by like nothing is really happening. I can also understand from a bystanders perspective, they don’t want to hassle themselves with the fact that they might have to deal with the kidnappers and get themselves in danger as well. So its also very understandable that most people just want to get on the day and not stress themselves with even more trouble. Though, there was an older woman that did dial 911 to call for help, showing that some were willing to give up time to help the others in need/danger.
In this scenario, I think some of the responses were not centered around the mindset of “oh, I’ll wait for someone else to help”, but more around the uncertainty of the situation. Some of the test subjects might have believed that she was just a misbehaving child and decided to mind their own business. I do think, however, that once it became clear this wasn’t simply misbehavior, more people should have stepped in. Even if it wasn’t very clear, someone should have made sure. You never know when it could be a kidnapping, and you just quietly walk by. Kudos to the people who actually helped, though.
After watching this video, I understand that more people in the world are afraid to get involved when in a situation such as in the video. After watching videos of such things I am not surprised of people´s actions and thought. People in life are not willing to help others unless they have been in a situation before.The only thing that upsets me is the fact that the people did not call the police. Like that is taught at such a young age and doing that would take much time out of their lives forget the fact that it could save someones life.
I think in a situation like this most of the people don’t want to get involved because they don’t know what is going to happen after. This is a life and death situation because that guy could have a gun, and people prefer to avoid it in order to be safe. A question that comes to my mind is, what about if that child was your sibling, cousin, or a child you know? You would do anything to help him/her. However, there are people that have the courage for situations like this one, as the two men that tried to help.
In this scenario I would have assumed that people would be much more likely to intervene due to the fact that the victim was a young girl and the assailant was a grown man. But, surprisingly, the majority of people just walked by, maybe glancing back once or twice to see what was going on. If this situation was real, and this young girl was abducted, I wonder what would go through their minds knowing that they easily could have called the police or intervened themselves. I understand that some people do not want to put themselves at risk, but if they were to just walk around the corner and notify the police than they would be at little to no risk at all.
so unbelievable, how people can choose to down look such an important issue. a kid yelling helplessly for help, and people just walk and do not help. its a shame , but that is how individuals think and reason, running away from responsibilities hoping somebody else will do it.
It’s kind of unbelievable to think that it took so long for people to actually react to a little girl screaming that the person grabbing her wasn’t her father. I think the people that just walked away weren’t trying to be cruel and yeah they were thinking that maybe someone else would get involved but another thing is that they maybe would think that the little girl was just saying that to be disobedient if it was her father.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The thought of someone hurting a child is absolutely heart breaking. I have children of my own and just thinking something bad could happen to them is so scary. So to see this video and watch people just walk by makes really mad. What is wrong with people? Why is it so hard to do the right thing? I saw some comments that stated that the scenario was obvious. Even if that is the case I wouldn’t be willing to assume I was right. I would rather be safe then sorry and I would approach them and check on the child. It takes 1 min to potentially save a child’s life. Nothing should be more important than that.
In the video, it is an absolute heartbreaking thing to watch the people who are passing by the child and the “kidnapper”, just look, but not react. While some of the people were in their own world and minding their own business, the others like the old couple clearly heard what the girl was saying and kept staring at them, but did not do anything. At the end of the video, they showed how 3 young men saw that something wasn’t quite right and immediately acted. I think everyone has their own means of contributing to save the child. Whether it is by physical force, or by calling the cops or for more help from others to catch the kidnapper.
The experiment shows that not only does the bystander effect affect adults in danger, but people in society are also as heartless as to not even help little children in society. Children are known to represent innocence and it’s shocking that more people wouldn’t want to do something to protect that little girl that was put in fake danger. When everyone has the mindset to stick to their own business and let everyone else do their thing and help people, then nothing gets accomplished and we are divided and vulnerable as a community.
Its not shocking what happened here. The diffusion of responsibility is most evident in everyday life. The more people present the least likely one is going to help out. A simple 911 call could have done but people here couldn’t even be bothered with that. They say the mood someone is in at times is a results at how one would react. You can be so pissed off at the world you couldn’t care less about a kid being kidnapped and while emotions is also a factor in this so are logical thinking. Think about it like this, I often wondered why people who witnessed a crime go down would fawn dumbness and claim not to have seen anything until I saw documentaries and tv shows that showed how a witness life is affected. How a legal system can take a toll on there life and those around them. Day in and day out of court, you end up with a person thinking If I report this crime, I become embodied into a very long exhausting legal matter about what I saw or didn’t see. I rather not. A person can think its more trouble than its worth. Not a lot of people have a self sacrificing element to them others only serve one master, themselves.
It was disheartening to watch people just walk away from the scene that was taking place
in front of them, not even making sure if she was alright or not. Those people might have feared for their own safety but could they not think about the children involved in the situation? Those children are more vulnerable and defenseless than the adults.
The child was clearly saying “You’re not my dad” “Someone help me” yet people still chose to walk away. Just like what the lady said, people assume that someone else will take action but if everyone witnessing the situation thinks that way then WHO would end
up TAKING action?
The fact that someone saw this happening and did nothing about it disgusts me. How can someone have the heart to let this happen. This honestly scares me. This little girl clearly says “You are not my dad”. And people still decide to walk by and do nothing about it. At least call the police. I know if that was me i would have done something . Its crazy to think that this is real. People walking by watching everything happen but do absolutely nothing about it. I get that people feared there own safety but this is a little girl if your not going to do anything about it then call for help, scream do something in order to get this girl help.
Like the Bystander Effect, this social experiment is very similar to each other. I expected more people to help the little girl out, simply because most people think of kids to be more vulnerable to danger, especially with an dominating figure around. If I were down the street and saw the scene, I would’ve confronted to the man and call the police because I am not fit to fight back, only distract the man from further harming the child. I think people were hesitant to help because they might’ve assumed it was a disobedient child and a guardian, but even then, there were suspicions when the child called out, “You’re not my dad! Stop it!”
Passing by a misbehaving kids, happen to as all the time and most of the time I try not to look to the parents, I feel that they are already embarrassed by what happening and they don’t need our judging look. I went to believe that what was happening here, people are thinking she is just having a bad day., and they don’t went to to anger the father more. Still they should wait and see if he is taking her somewhere or he is welling to heart her.
I am physically too small to have stood a chance and I am not confident in my ability to be able to stand a fighting chance. Instead, I would have called the police or talked to someone around me about the matter and come up with a solution.
it is nice to see that two gentlemen had the guts to stand up to this stunt. so many others were willing to turn a blind eye at the possibility of a young child being kidnapped or hurt badly. a lot like the bystander effect, this shows that people still act similarly to the way they did half a century ago. more people need to see this type of video and behavior to wake up to the reality.
In the clip, there are some people notice to what’s going on on the street. However, they do not like to interfere. When people see the crowd without reactions, this is a sign that they may not need to do anything. Bystander effect may affect the action of helping the kid to escape from the kidnapper. In such chaotic moments, people often look at others to see what they should do accordingly. In fact, no one likes to disturb or take responsibility for others when they do not know exactly what is going on.
Yes, it is all about accountability and social responsibility! Good Job!
It’s really frightening that our society don’t want to get involved in incidents like this. I think a lot of people are like why would I take responsibility, they want other people do that. Those people walked by her absolutely knew that the girl was in danger because she was clearly saying “help me, he is not my dad”. I honestly wouldn’t run towards him to save her because I would worry for my own safety, but I would call the police immediately. I think we should all think that it could happen to our kids or some one we know.
As a human being and a father this would stand out to me and I would not ignore the situation. Many times, we hear in the news of children gone missing and children being abused, the majority of the time not a good end. First I would observe to see what’s going on, hearing a child yelling would naturally draw my attention. As soon I heard her saying you’re not my dad I would quickly call the police. I would feel so guilty to later see on the news that this incident happened and if I intervened it could have been avoided. When we rely on others to take actions for us, we fail to protect those that are weak and not able to fend for themselves. Society needs our eyes and ears because this could have happened to one of our loved ones or our next-door neighbor. Stay alert!
In this clip is showing us how people react to something that is happening, like the people in the video that decide to avoid, or not listen to what is happening and also that they keep looking and they do not try to help the girl that is in problems. Also why people avoid it, because they were thinking that some one was going to take action and help the little girl, that is one mistake in this part because they think that but that is not going to happen until the end of the clip in witch three guys decide to take action and help the little girl and that show that is really important to help others when they need it. In addition the police officer was shock when he saw all this people just walking and not doing anything. This clip show the important to notice what is happening around you and help other when they need help.
I realize that in the U. S. people does not like to get involved in other people’s business. We often hear people say “mind your own business” so they carry this mentality with them. Looking at both videos, it is frightened to see that no one was willing to help especially in Ketty’s case when it is a matter of life or death. It could have been me or any one else. In the case of the child abductor, I think people thought it was a child who is misbehaving and did not want to get involve. However, when the child screamed “ you are not my dad” people should have helped. It could have been their own children being abducted. In general, I think that people usually fear for their own safety and afraid to get involved especially when they see other people do not react. However, it only take one person to act for the other bystanders to act also. If it was me, I would assess the situation, call 911 and get involved if it is safe but if it is not safe, I could call 911.
Jean Robert J Belande
The first time I watched this video, I wasn’t that all surprised. As someone who is quite meek and small, I would not have any chance standing up against that man. I think that I would further escalate the situation to become worse than it already was. I’m sure others were freaked out about getting into that type of situation. I mean, who wouldn’t? Rewatching it now though, I am surprised that no one attempted to call the police. I understand that people are scared of putting themselves in danger, but to not do anything at all is absolutely selfish. In my perspective, I’d like to think I would help or at least do something, but I guess I wouldn’t know until I am actually placed in that situation. Also, the phrase, “better safe than sorry,” as cliché as it sounds, ideally applies to the situation. This situation clearly portrays people surrendering to the Bystander Effect.
I was not so surprised that Kitty Genovese didn’t get help from her neighbors because that what we do as an humans not putting ourselves in a danger position someone for someone else. Bystanders Effect happens every single day in our life that we do not stand up to help others because we assume that there is always some else would start helping them before we do. However, I would try to get help for Kitty if I was one of the 38 people. Even though if I wasn’t helping directly by going outside, but I could try to get help from other ways by keeping my lighting on or scream through the window just scare the murder through the window. If we watch someone suffers and die front of us and we don’t get help for them therefore, we are more likely would not get help from others when we getting into the same position.
I like to think that still has hope… and watching this video brings us awareness, and maybe the next time we witness some weird situation, we will take the risk and step up to help.
The negative reaction to an ongoing assault against a victim is a common public behavior a long time before its gets the scientific name “Bystander Effect”. In my real life a witnessed one of this assault against a young girl in the middle of night when an adult man was trying to grape her against her will, and nobody in that street did anything to help the girl. I learned a lot from this experience and i like to share it with you and what i have learned from. First, I asked the girl if she know the man or he is a member of the family, why? because it can be a family business or a couple business, and that may put me in a situation nobody will support me for involving, and I can get in trouble for that. And that is just one reason why people dont get the courage to involve. They are afraid to be another victim, or maybe their involvement will be a matter of questioning. or can be forced to witness against the assaulter Who can be a treat to witnesses. And that may be one reason for the common advice of parents to their children to not involve in others fight, and to not talk to the police as witness. That happens usually in the most dangerous neighborhoods. At that night nobody react, but as i get in ش fight with the assaulter, Another man fled the girl and I was the new victim. I had the courage and I was was prepared physically and mentally to manage saving the girl and saving myself after that. But most of people relay on there instinct to be safe in this situation by staying away. From where i came, theses things append on daily basis. And i has no name, because nobody care.
Another terrifying example of the bystander effect. I would like to think that I would help if something like this happened but I will hopefully never know. These experiments are terrifying to see but as they get around more people might think twice before letting something like this happen freely.
Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:
You are commenting using your WordPress.com account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Google+ account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Twitter account.
( Log Out /
You are commenting using your Facebook account.
( Log Out /
Connecting to %s
Notify me of new comments via email.
Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Powered by WordPress.com.